Bumpersticker Theology

Jesus was a Liberal.

Rick had an interesting post talking about the need to be liberal in how we love each other. I agree with him. Here’s a snippet:

I even heard someone say, liberal Christians talk about following the teachings of Jesus but not about following Jesus. How can one follow the teachings of Jesus without following Jesus? Wouldn’t this suggest that it is possible to follow Jesus without following his teachings?
Many of the folks I know who claim to follow Jesus actually follow John Calvin’s understanding of Paul.

So, I looked up the word liberal.

According to Webster it means, not limited to or by established, traditional, orthodox, or authoritarian attitudes, views, or dogmas; free from bigotry. Favoring proposals for reform, open to new ideas for progress, and tolerant of the ideas and behavior of others.

That sounds like the Jesus I read about in the Gospels!

In the comments, Mac had a few good points about the flip side of Christianity, where liberalism pulls Jesus out just as fundamentalism does:

My reading of this blog tells me that most here are very CLEAR on the dangers of Fundamentalism in America and how anti-Gospel it is. There is simply no “good news” in any religion based in fear and control.

But as a Liberal (both politically and theologically) I still recognize the bankruptcy of traditional liberal Christianity and it’s decline in mainline denominations.

It’s decline came from it’s own kind of fear (and arogance…they often go together). They were so worried about being “legitimate” in the face of Modernity, that they capitulated to it.

Lots of food for thought there. My frustration with this (as in politics) is that the middle gets lost. As I’ve said before, I often get a bit of exposure to rightwing media when I spend time with my parents — FOXNews, Rush, O’Reilly, Hannity, etc. If I listened to these as my sole sources of news, you know, I’d worry about the liberal too, I suppose. By the same token, if I listened only to Air America Radio, I’d probably demonize Republicans/Conservatives much more as well. Each side has such fears of the other — that the other side has a conspiracy against it, and they’re out to destroy us!

Back to religion, I especially see this in today’s evangelical conservative Christianity, but then I’ve always seen that — I just used to see it from within, and now I’m outside viewing as an observer. In visiting a blog a few minutes ago (the one where I found the compatibility test), I read a post where the author talked about how she fears that the removal of things like “under God” from the Pledge signify a dangerous turn in our schools, and how she hopes that when she has children, her living a godly life will counterbalance the anti-christianity they will likely encounter in school. I’m not doing her words justice (and have already lost the blog site, oops), but to me, this is a pretty good example of the sorts of fears I see often coming from the religious right.

Removing a reference to God does not necessarily mean *adding* anti-Christian sentiment. It doesn’t mean an attack. It’s simply the removal of something pro-Christian. (Personally, I think removing “under God” from the pledge is not a big deal either way…) There’s a spectrum of action here, and the middle is again ignored.

pro-Christian — neutral — anti-Christian

IMO, we’re moving toward the middle, not toward anti-C…but in many cases, any move away from pro-Christianity is labeled as an attack. No, it’s not an attack. It’s simply stopping “you” from preaching to me. The recent USAFA scandal fell into this category as well.

I’m rambling now, but that’s not exactly new, is it? :-P


4 Responses to “Bumpersticker Theology”  

  1. 1 Mac

    Hi Allison. New to your site. I really like it. Thanks for your comments.

    The polarization is as you describe. I am wondering (aloud) if what we have not missed is simply, “the Center” who is Christ Himself.

    I’m gonna peruse around here for a bit.

  2. 2 Mac

    Oh…Allison…also…here is a link to a site I work on that you may enjoy.

    http://doghouseministries.blogspot.com/

    The “Jesus Outed” article, while long, is a fun read (I hope).

    I got your info from Rick Luoni’s site. He and I are locals here and he is a most amazing man.

  3. 3 danutz

    just ran across your site and I have bit to share. I apologize in advance for the length…

    I think the polarization problem we have is a vicious cycle bread out of a total lack of real communication. I spent most of my life in conservative religion and politics. After viewing the hostile climate building through this polarization I got sick of it. I felt the only thing I could was to reach out (across the isle) and stop being so fearful of the ideas I would find. I realized that all my conservative friends (and my self) had something in common.. they only conversed with conservatives, they only listed to conservative talk radio, they only watched conservative news programming, they only read conservative books (political and religious). There was no way they could be anything other than conservatives.

    I decided to stop the insanity. I knew very well that there were intelligent liberals. They couldn’t be all idiots… could they? I bought my first liberal book. I had no idea what I was getting into, but I was determined not to pick apart their ideas but to understand there frame of reference. I wanted to be sure it was a person of faith (even if I knew I would disagree on specific issues). The first book was “I don’t care what the Bible says” by Kenneth Cauthen. That sounded controversial enough!!! Well, it wasn’t what I thought.

    It turns out I have much in common with Cauthen. Our southern roots and our struggle to play out our faith in the deep south were points of commonality. Before I knew it I grew to admire him and completely understood why he left both the south and the conservative church. Soon I bought one of his theological books and that led to others like Marcus Borg and Bishop Shelby Spong. My view of God and my view of others will never be the same. My life has been changed because I took a step beyond my comfort zone and cared more about reconciliation than self-promotion.

    I don’t want to give the idea this is a tale of turning to the dark side. I’m neither conservative or liberal. From a political perspective I could only vote for Libertarians. Both our major parties are corrupt beyond hope of salvation. Both parties (parties not people) should please die and go straight to hell ASAP before they comletely destroy our country! But I share this stroy wherever possible in a hope that people will come to realize there are valid reasons for all sorts of views on God and Politics. What is really important is to get to know the people behind the views before we judge them.

  4. 4 Kenneth Cauthen

    Thank you for your kinf words about me and out common interests. I suspect we could find a lot more that put us in the same camp, although my theology by now is far left.
    Ken